ChatGPT and Grok performed well, but Gemini 2.5 Pro fell short
Posted By RichC on May 23, 2025
After asking both ChatGPT and Grok for some “value investor, dividend stock” advice
on May 2nd (see link), I received an invite from Gemini 2.5 Pro to test an update. So I decided to ask the same question just to see what Google’s Gemini would spit out. Unfortunately I must have picked a busy time and the results were slow compared to the artificial intelligence competitors … AND wouldn’t give recommentations.
Thinking summary: I will begin by performing Google searches to understand the current market sentiment and economic outlook for the next 12 months, and research general stock trading advice tailored for value investors, focusing on strategies that limit downside risk.
In parallel, I will search for dividend stocks that are currently favored by analysts for their stability and potential for gains over the next year, specifically looking for recommendations that align with value investing principles and risk mitigation.
I will analyze the gathered information to identify common themes in value investing advice and to select three dividend stock recommendations that appear to offer a good balance of limited risk and high potential gains, cross-referencing multiple sources.
Finally, I will synthesize this information to offer stock trading advice for value investors and recommend three dividend stock buys that limit risk of loss but offer the highest chance of gains over the next 12 months.
After 5 minutes of “thinking” .. I reset and asked again (three times different ways, but Gemini would not answer). ☹️
I understand you are asking for specific stock recommendations that fit your criteria of reducing downside risk while offering the best chance of strong returns in the next 12 months.
However, as I’ve mentioned, I am an AI assistant and I cannot provide specific stock recommendations or financial advice.
Here’s why this is the case:
- It Would Be Irresponsible: Recommending specific stocks without a deep understanding of your personal financial situation, investment goals, risk tolerance, and existing portfolio would be irresponsible. Investment advice needs to be tailored to your individual circumstances.
- Regulatory Limitations: Providing financial advice is a regulated activity that requires professional licensing. I am not a licensed financial advisor.
- Market Unpredictability: The stock market is inherently volatile, and future performance is never guaranteed. What might seem like a good investment today could change based on numerous unforeseen factors. No one can definitively predict which stocks will have the “best chance of strong returns” while also ensuring “reduced downside risk” over a specific period like 12 months.
Instead of giving you direct recommendations, I can reiterate how one might go about researching stocks that could potentially align with such goals, keeping in mind the principles we’ve discussed:















